The Other Side
Ken Bontrager
July 25, 2020
Second of Four / 2020 Essays on Race and Diversity
Camp Deerpark, from the beginning in 1969, has been a place where people of all cultures have come together to break down barriers. A few weeks ago Kevin Smith shared his perspective on race relations and diversity. Following is the second of four short essays from my perspective.
I have been honored and blessed to have been invited into many conversations and experiences over the past 37 years which have shaped and enriched my life. Ms. Mary Joseph told me the key is changing the heart, not the laws. Dr. Drew Hart challenged me to push into knowing the other side. Jesus called both a tax collector and a zealot to be his disciples. And finally, David Miller stressed Imago Dei, the importance of seeing every person as made in the image of God.
My experience has shown me that breaking down racial stereotypes and prejudices happens best with one-on-one relationships. I have been honored to be in several relationships where honest and loving communication has helped me see the world differently.
In 2018 I had the privilege of reading Trouble I’ve Seen by Dr. Drew G.I. Hart (which we highly recommend). Dr. Hart also agreed to share with our small group of Peace Camp participants that summer. We were grateful that he was able to carve out the time and fully engage with our small group. Dr. Hart tells a story of an encounter with a white suburban pastor. Sitting in Mc Donald’s with a tall cup of sweet tea between them the pastor suggested, “This cup has writing on my side of the cup and a logo on yours. But I can’t see what is on your side of the cup. Likewise, you can’t see what is on my side of the cup.” Dr. Hart writes, “After explaining why I already knew what was on his side of the cup, I continued on. I noted that in contrast to me, he most likely could go through his entire life without needing to know black literature, black intellectual thought, black wisdom, black art and music, or black history. That is, he could choose to never engage with or be changed by the range of beauty of the black community. Nor would he be penalized for it.”
When I arrived in the Bronx as an eighteen-year-old, Michael Banks invited me to move around the cup and see the world from his perspective. He was ten years older than me and treated me somewhere between a son and a little brother. We obviously had many disagreements and misunderstandings, but we were always family and Michael always told me the truth with love. He gently pulled me around the cup to see the beauty and struggle of life from his side.
We don’t always get it right, but we have to keep pushing in. Just a few weeks ago I was on a zoom call with several other directors of camps that serve inner city youth. One long-time and very accomplished African-American director shared his frustration with being talked down to by a white foundation administrator. With pain and frustration in his voice he told us, “Other than the color of my skin, there was no reason for him to think I would not know the difference between interest and principle. And they didn’t give us the grant.” Instead of just listening and trying to understand his frustration, I jumped in and told my own story of being declined a gift request. Not his point at all. I missed the opportunity to see his side of the cup and, instead, wanted him to see my side.
I encourage my white brothers and sisters to press into knowing, understanding, and experiencing the other side of the cup. Learn African-American and Latino culture and history. Pursue friendships that will authentically move you to the other side of the cup. If you mess up like I have hundreds of times, dust yourself off and get back at it. If you find this to be uncomfortable, please know that uncomfortable is like a muscle that can be strengthened. It is not the responsibility of our friends of color to make us comfortable. It is our responsibility to strengthen the uncomfortability muscle.
May God give us grace.
Previous Essay: Whose Side Are You On? | Next Essay: Peter and Matthew
Related Entries
Share:
“How Do I Donate?”
Recently, a thirteen-year-old guest at Camp asked Operations Director Kevin Smith, “how do I donate?” Kevin was honestly a little surprised, but was happy to see this young member – who was on retreat with one of our owning churches — taking some initiative. Kevin directed him to the website Donate page, and the young…
The Discipleship Down-Low
Defining Discipleship 18 And Jesus came and said to them, “All authority in heaven and on earth has been given to me. 19 Go therefore and make disciples of all nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit, 20 teaching them to observe all that I have commanded…
The Virtuous Wife
This past weekend, Camp hosted three women’s retreats at Camp. Though the retreat groups were very diverse in background – one was from an urban church plant in Philadelphia, one was from a Garifuna Mennonite church in Brooklyn (an Afro-Caribbean Culture), and one was from a multi-ethnic faith community reaching out in North Jersey. Though…
A Life of Service
I believe the most important thing to God is not our personality, knowledge, or talents, but our availability. How willing and ready are we to respond when He calls, and how ready are we to do what He says? What use to the Lord are people who could do what he wants with excellence and…
Building Belonging
At our February NYC LMC District meeting, we’re discussing the Belonging phase of The Journey Map. In this first phase on the map, individuals and groups on a spiritual journey begin the process of connecting to each other and evaluating the place they may have in each other’s lives. Have you ever been an outsider…
What Are You Tapped Into?
Yesterday we began tapping maple trees, officially opening maple syrup making season at Camp Deerpark! Last year, the transition kept us from producing syrup, so it feels great to be back to it. Starting off, however, has been a bit of a challenge since things are pretty arctic around here. The entire ground is covered…
What Does it Mean to be Spirit-Led with Pastor Mark Perri
One small contribution I can make is to share story with you. This could be valuable in several ways: First, I’m coming to the Mennonites from the outside — from non-denominational GenX “simple/ organic/ emergent church“. Sometimes people coming from outside-in have a helpful perspective for those trying to move from inside-out. Second, as an…
2025 NYC LMC District Call Schedule
Mark these dates in your calendar if you’re part of the NYC LMC District and want to attend the English-language fellowship and resourcing calls led by Bishop Hyacinth Stevens: January 27th – 6:30 PM February 24th – 6:30 PM March 31st – 6:30 PM April 28th – 6:30 PM May 19th – 6:30 PM June 30th…
Winter: Life Under the Surface
On the surface, winter with its cracking and cold seems like the enemy of life. Everything sleeps as though dead, and Camp — quiet and empty — sits waiting. But under the surface, winter is revealed to be a friend to life, not an enemy. In the deep frost, God opens the soil for Spring’s…
Peace Making Presents
This is Session 4 of the Prince of Peace: Jesus and Peacebuilding from the Election to the Holidays webinar series. Advent celebrates the central fact that God began building peace with us by giving a Gift. Following this example, gifts are a powerful tool for peacebuilding in our lives, relationships, and organizations. We’ll explore how…